?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Ender's Game is morally repugnant

As I hear friends and acquaintances express eagerness to see the Ender's Game film that will be released this fall, I have a hard time responding. I want to ask, have you read the book? After you were fifteen years old? And you enjoyed it? I can't understand how it won the awards it did. It's not just poorly written, it's repugnant. John Kessel articulates why in his essay Creating the Innocent Killer:
Ender's Game, Intention, and Morality
. An excerpt:
We see the effects of displaced, righteous rage everywhere around us, written in violence and justified as moral action, even compassion. Ender gets to strike out at his enemies and still remain morally clean. Nothing is his fault. Stilson already lies defeated on the ground, yet Ender can kick him in the face until he dies, and still remain the good guy. Ender can drive bone fragments into Bonzo’s brain and then kick his dying body in the crotch, yet the entire focus is on Ender’s suffering. For an adolescent ridden with rage and self-pity, who feels himself abused (and what adolescent doesn’t?), what’s not to like about this scenario? So we all want to be Ender. As Elaine Radford has said, “We would all like to believe that our suffering has made us special—especially if it gives us a righteous reason to destroy our enemies.”

But that’s a lie. No one is that special; no one is that innocent. If I felt that Card’s fiction truly understood this, then I would not have written this essay.


This entry was originally posted at http://bokunenjin.dreamwidth.org/38505.html.

Tags:

Comments

( 3 comments — Leave a comment )
mimerki
May. 17th, 2013 05:29 pm (UTC)
I first read Ender's Game in my mid-twenties. I didn't find it exactly repugnant but I did see very clearly that I would have loved it as an early teen and that I was glad I hadn't read it then. But saying that one wouldn't go so far as to call a book "repugnant" is also not to be mistaken for glowing praise: It's a terrible book in all of the ways described and then some.
(Deleted comment)
thewronghands
May. 20th, 2013 03:00 pm (UTC)
I can totally see this. I didn't quite have that kind of adolescence myself, but I had a rough one where I felt put-upon by the world. So I wouldn't have had the "yeah!" rage response and self-identification with the hero in that way, but I know so many of my friends did. (It would have been the "so much smarter than everyone else and no one understaaaaands" hubris that would have gotten me.) But between that and Card's upsetting comments on GLBT people, yeah, I don't want to give him any money.
( 3 comments — Leave a comment )